• Powered by
  • Newsvine:

 

 

Stories of struggle and recovery in America: Msnbc.com is focusing long-term coverage on the city of Elkhart, Ind. to provide perspective on the national recession. Follow our ongoing coverage on msnbc.com. Want to share your thoughts on the how the recession is playing out in Elkhart or in your community? Comment on any of the blog posts below or become a blog contributor. Learn how

Full coverage | Why Elkhart? | More about our team

Follow this project via ...
advertisement
{"contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}

A new way for readers to contribute

To broaden the discussion of the recession's impact and what appears to be the beginning of a recovery, msnbc.com is offering readers a new way to participate in the Elkhart Project.

The Elkhart Project blog, formerly reserved for our reporters' posts, will now serve as a community forum as well as a place where you can help steer the conversation by sharing your thoughts and observations about what's happening in Elkhart or in your community.

Here's how it works: Register for Newsvine (if you haven't done so already) and publish an article to your column that relates to The Elkhart Project. Before publishing, be sure to add "Elkhart" to the tags field so that our editors will be alerted when your article appears on Newsvine. If our editors feel that your writing is a good fit for the Elkhart Project Blog, we'll send you an email notifying you that you've been added as a member. You will then be able to publish directly to the Elkhart Project Blog.

Our editors will review articles published to the blog to ensure that they have something to do with the economy and otherwise meet Newsvine's publication standards (please see the Newsvine Code of Honor). Posts that aren't appropriate for the Elkhart Project Blog may be removed, but will remain in your Newsvine column.

That's all there is to it. Let the conversation begin.

{"contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
{"commentId":9500978,"authorDomain":"laurah-1"}

Why are we supposed to care so much about Elkhart? There are plenty of other towns suffering from the recession and getting no attention.

{"commentId":9500978,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"laurah-1"}
    Reply#1 - Tue Sep 15, 2009 4:24 PM EDT
    {"commentId":9523432,"authorDomain":"brunker"}

    The basic notion of this project is that we're using Elkhart to show the local impact of the recession, since our reporters can't be everywhere. But that's why we're hoping that some readers will contribute and compare and contrast what's happening in their community with goings on in Elkhart.

    {"commentId":9523432,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"brunker"}
      #1.1 - Wed Sep 16, 2009 11:21 AM EDT
      {"commentId":9532887,"authorDomain":"gretchha-1"}

      OK, they may be true, but anytime I see Elkhart prom or Elkhart diner or Elkhart dogs, my eyes roll into the back of my head. I do not read the stories. Just shake my head. It would have been so much cooler if you would have done a different city a week or month or watched a couple of cities. Maybe one in the south where I am. You know, the area everyone says in teaming with rednecks. Yee Ha.

      {"commentId":9532887,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"gretchha-1"}
        #1.2 - Wed Sep 16, 2009 4:26 PM EDT
        Reply
        {"commentId":9503098,"authorDomain":"gretchha-1"}

        I'm tired of Elkhart.

        {"commentId":9503098,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"gretchha-1"}
          Reply#2 - Tue Sep 15, 2009 5:41 PM EDT
          {"commentId":9510798,"authorDomain":"GunnyCoop"}

          AMEN.

          {"commentId":9510798,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"GunnyCoop"}
            #2.1 - Tue Sep 15, 2009 10:02 PM EDT
            Reply
            {"commentId":9510618,"authorDomain":"GunnyCoop"}

            Your editors will decide if you are good enough to join the club. Get a life. Drop Elkhart and report real news. Fire the "journalist" that keeps nagging at your index page. I'm getting ready to drop Newsvine. Get a life. Lets see if you post this. A minute and 30 to go.....are you watching??

            {"commentId":9510618,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"GunnyCoop"}
              Reply#3 - Tue Sep 15, 2009 9:56 PM EDT
              {"commentId":9544223,"authorDomain":"juju011"}

              Gunny, maybe some of the post I make might interest you then. Please don't grow tired of Elkhart, that is what put us in the situation we are in now.

              {"commentId":9544223,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"juju011"}
                Reply#4 - Thu Sep 17, 2009 5:33 AM EDT
                {"commentId":9548150,"authorDomain":"KeepingReal"}

                Whether you live in Elkhart or anywhere else in the Country, there is more than one side to dealing with the economic downfalls. Has anyone taken the time to talk to Welfare Caseworkers who are overloaded by the system and down-graded by the recipients? It's sad, but true.

                {"commentId":9548150,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"KeepingReal"}
                  Reply#5 - Thu Sep 17, 2009 11:05 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":9551441,"authorDomain":"KeepingReal"}

                  Whether you live in Elkhart or anywhere else in the Country, there is more than one side to dealing with the economic downfalls. Has anyone taken the time to talk to Welfare Caseworkers who are overloaded by the system and down-graded by the recipients? It's sad, but true.

                  {"commentId":9551441,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"KeepingReal"}
                    Reply#6 - Thu Sep 17, 2009 1:26 PM EDT
                    {"commentId":9563837,"authorDomain":null}

                    Enough already! I set MSNBC.com as a home/startup page as a startup news source for over 8 years when I logon, but what's up with the constant "Elkhart Project" "news" being forever shoved down our throats!? What an irrelevant long term focus point for any MSNBC journalists' career. Completely boring and news unworthy. News flash! Every town is hurting, so when I want a feel good/bad quasi-news story I will buy a copy of PEOPLE or tune into TODAY. Quit feeling bad for one part of America where nobody has every heard of and trying to spin it like "Elkhart" Indiana is the ground zero for the recession. Get back to reporting the news as it develops and not as as a science project. If I fed you email/spam about the face of Leland NC for as long as you have been feeding the public about E Indiana you would be getting as nauscious as we all are now. News shouldn't be a reality show!

                    The recession is real, but ELKHART Project is really hard to deal with day after day after day after day....................

                    {"commentId":9563837,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936"}
                      Reply#7 - Thu Sep 17, 2009 11:55 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":9569587,"authorDomain":"juju011"}

                      Funny you posted with no name...

                      I am soo sorry you are sick of our struggle, but our story is the story of the entire nation. This IS just one city. But it is the city MSNBC chose to report on. Deal with it. We will be in your faces until the struggle is over. We will tell our story until there is no story. We will continue to put ourselves out there like an open book until everyone in every city gets the support they need. We tell our story so other people in other cities have something or someone to relate to. Hopefully some of these stories will give someone the hope they need to not give up.

                      {"commentId":9569587,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"juju011"}
                        #7.1 - Fri Sep 18, 2009 10:50 AM EDT
                        {"commentId":9760620,"authorDomain":"Bartofelkhart"}

                        With the story of Elkhart, some are stories of hope and struggle. The stories that are here, not only affect the mainstream but the diverse as well. Did you not notice the story about the Amish? They are the most down to earth people who have slowly lost some of their heritage to the mainstream that has grown around them. They are affected as well. Not only with their jobs but with those that sell their handcrafted furniture, quilts and other finely handcrafted items you can't find in stores. This is America on a whole. Some are worse off than others. Some towns are doing fine.

                        I know that this all gets you down, because, maybe it affects you. If not, don't complain. Some day, this may be in your face and we'll be reading about your hardship.

                        {"commentId":9760620,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"Bartofelkhart"}
                          #7.2 - Mon Sep 28, 2009 8:34 PM EDT
                          Reply
                          {"commentId":9585706,"authorDomain":"pembek"}

                          Jholderread

                          Good for you!!! Stand up for your city...it's what more people need to do...show that local spirit of support so these little towns don't end up more economically depressed. it starts with the heart!

                          {"commentId":9585706,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"pembek"}
                            Reply#8 - Fri Sep 18, 2009 11:58 PM EDT
                            {"commentId":9615529,"authorDomain":"markbudosfit"}

                            Test

                            {"commentId":9615529,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"markbudosfit"}
                              Reply#9 - Sun Sep 20, 2009 11:21 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":9618226,"authorDomain":"cmcmark76"}

                              Elkart is just a snap shot of America but their story is being played out in a thousand Elkharts.  And for millions of Americans they have their own personal Elkhart.

                              I had my own job loss and one part of my story is here:

                              http://www.helium.com/items/1535170-tuning-a-negative-into-a-positive-after-a-job-loss

                              There are more articles about how I dealt with job loss and budget issues there also and I did my share of learning.  Perhaps there is something that will help you there too.

                              Good Luck and Good Job Hunting!

                              {"commentId":9618226,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"cmcmark76"}
                                Reply#10 - Mon Sep 21, 2009 9:30 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":9637099,"authorDomain":"TurboButterfly"}

                                Elkhart may be just like a thousand other towns in the US. But each of us have a very personal story, with personal hurts and feelings. I lost my job when a greedy corporation moved my manufactoring job to Mexico and Canada. They wanted more profits. I got the TAA training, and I have been looking for work for the past 6 months. I have had two offers in my field of study, (Medical Coding and Billing) and even that it was for $8.74 an hour; way below my 12.95 I was earning. I would have had to sell my home and move 250 miles to take it. Now with unemployment running out in Arkansas, I am applying at any place with open doors. I will work at about any thing to keep my home and car. I do hang my head, and really I have nothing to be ashamed of. I have worked hard, followed the rules, and yet I may be homeless in a few short months. Even if I sold the home and rented, the rent around my area is higher than my home payment. It is a vicious cycle and I am not sure if it will end. If higher paying jobs are not developed, people are going to be living in proverty again soon.

                                {"commentId":9637099,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"TurboButterfly"}
                                  Reply#11 - Tue Sep 22, 2009 9:28 AM EDT
                                  {"commentId":9760443,"authorDomain":"Bartofelkhart"}

                                  You have no need to hang your head. You are not the failure here. You did what you were supposed to do and your employer let you down. The govt has allowed jobs to be outsourced and with higher taxes and tariff things the govt does, is what hurt us. Made in the USA no longer can be found on quality items as it was 30 or 40 years ago. Remember when Sam Walton, founder of WalMart would only sell products made in America? What we have lost, is the confidence in our leaders to keep it here. Butterfly, I wish you well and to keep your head up! For now, that $8.74 hr job will help but keep looking and keep putting those apps in. Network with friends and family but don't give up hope! None of us can.

                                  {"commentId":9760443,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"Bartofelkhart"}
                                    #11.1 - Mon Sep 28, 2009 8:24 PM EDT
                                    Reply
                                    {"commentId":9675913,"authorDomain":"chrisvanbekkum"}

                                    what is the use for training (at government expense) for a new carreer if this "carreer " is just an illusion?? . the only job market that is exanding is :1) government (make work) jobs, 2) health care . For an electrician whose job just moved to Mumbay , wiping old folks butts is not really an option.

                                    {"commentId":9675913,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"chrisvanbekkum"}
                                      Reply#12 - Wed Sep 23, 2009 10:41 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":9980017,"authorDomain":"clementstory"}

                                      elkhart;

                                      The economic collapse of the worlds greatest experiment, our Republic, did not happen overnight. For the past 40 years and accelerating in the last 12, we began outsourcing our economy, for enhanced profits to the Multi- National corporations. We were warned repeatably by many businessmen, scholars and politicians that we were destroying our Nation; these persons were laughed , at and portrayed as fools. Remember Ross Periot, the media had a field day, painting him as a foolish man with big ears.

                                      We now must began a long term recovery, but first we must hold our elected officials responsible, we gave Trillions to bail out the Banks, auto, and insurance, only to have the money transferred to foreign holdings of the Multi-National banks, insurance and Financial institutions.

                                      It will take decades to repair what has been done; why not start now.

                                      {"commentId":9980017,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"clementstory"}
                                      • 1 vote
                                      Reply#13 - Fri Oct 9, 2009 3:44 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":10491218,"authorDomain":"PSOkiki"}

                                      Hi Anyone and Everyone....(for having "No interest...isn't it funny that you all have a LOT to say?)

                                           Okay, whew....deep breath, I KNOW that each and every one of us feels that "our" city deserves the same "attention." My guess is that if the folks at MSNBC had titled it the "Anytown, USA, Project" then there would be something ELSE to complain about. The point is that Elkhart COULD be ANY town in the United States and that the struggles, triumphs and little bitty, unheard of and uncared for teensy, tiny victories ARE the same things that are happening in "not-quite-metropolitan-but-we-still-REALLY-count" towns all over this chunk of real estate we all call home.

                                            I grew up in Elkhart and then went to college in another speck on the map, Kalamazoo, Michigan....by the way, has anyone ever heard of Derek Jeeter? Yeah..well, he grew up there. And THAT is the point! There are towns just like Elkhart all over the map and the stories of the people there could be the stories of anyone of y-o-u. If you take issue with msnbc's reporting style or their choice of topics...then why not spend your online time creating a blog that showcases your city? OR, if you want to really contribute to the good of EVERYone, then throw your thoughts for improvement, for...Change(!) into the arena. The sooner that everyone realizes that what solves the "problems" for one city helps solve the problems ALL of us have....the better off ALL of us will be. AND...the more quickly the United States can return to being truly a Super Power, in a new and better format, as well as an example for the rest of the planet. But I digress...lol...

                                           Here's some food for thought, I just read in the Elkart Truth's online E-dition (that's what I call it anyway...heehee...) that the Elkhart County Veterans Administration has extended benefits to veterans for three additional illnesses associated with exposure to Agent Orange. Now, with what little I know, (and excluding my personal feelings!) THIS could be newsworthy whether you're in Nowhere Alaska, or Nowhere, Alabama....(like me?..lol..) This sounds to me like it COULD just set a precedent...and that's what making news is all about. Catching the FIRST train to being new, different, or...a topic of conversation. I have to say this...even if you're "sick of hearing about Elkhart", you're all still talking. How's that saying go? Well, I don't know..but it says something about the fact that there's no such thing as "bad press." The name of this small town (which could be YOUR small town, don't think that the folks in Elkhart don't know that just as well as you do!) is on people's lips and that means that just maybe...the people's minds are on towns just like it all over the country. If we can gain momentum from the ground...perhaps by the time we reach Washington D.C. we can be a ground-swelling, foot-stomping...ummm...COHESIVE (?) majority. In spite of what the naysayers refrain states, it really DOES take just one person. (OR...one small nowhere city?)

                                      Born a Hoosier,

                                      Katrina

                                      {"commentId":10491218,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"PSOkiki"}
                                        Reply#14 - Thu Nov 5, 2009 10:10 AM EST
                                        {"commentId":10721646,"authorDomain":"aturner246"}

                                        I saw one of the Elkhart stories that profiled a guy who had a 9th grade education and had just gone back to work in the the RV factory- making $30 per hour. Made me wonder if the RV factory paid a little less they might could charge a little less and more people could afford one, making more business in the long run. All these stories seem to be originating from areas where people were over-paid to begin with and now don't want to get back into the real world. Seriously, $30/hr for a guy with a 9th grade education to put a part on an RV? No wonder factories are moving out of this country.

                                        {"commentId":10721646,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"aturner246"}
                                          Reply#15 - Tue Nov 17, 2009 10:10 AM EST
                                          {"commentId":10978670,"authorDomain":"Sunhunterwith2"}

                                          The "10-to-4 Plan" is an economic recovery roadmap.

                                          The "10-to-4 Plan" is a full employment plan with 17 components. By design, it stimulates employment opportunities in a wide variety of sectors to ensure economic prosperity reaches beyond Main Street to Side Streets and Back Streets.

                                          The 10-to-4 Plan will re-start mothballed, closed or idled factories and re-employ unemployed and underemployed workers. When executed, only the frictional unemployed (people who are transitioning from one employment opportunity to another) and the unemployable are not re-absorbed into the work force.

                                          The "10-to-4 Plan" addresses persistent problems in certain areas that effect cost containment issues in another area of federal funded programs.

                                          Moreover, the "10-to-4 Plan" creates jobs in a majority of Congressional districts to ensure support by the electorate and grass root organizers.

                                          The "10-to-4 Plan" does not throw "sand" into the gears of commerce. Rather, it strategically channels government-funded activities to maximize results and expedite re-starting of the domestic economy, which in turn will bring accelerated relief to our export-dependent trade partners.

                                          My clients ... and their former employees and customers ... in my first and second careers have been hurt. I feel their pain. I share his or her losses. Everyone shares the economic pain, including shareholders. A vacant factory in Elkhart, Braddock, Flint or Cleveland affects property values for everyone because demand for homes plummet when factories close. Beer companies, like Anheuser Busch, face shrinking profits when their customers switch brands from premium beers to low cost beer brands. Even automobile insurance companies, like Nationwide or Progressive, are hurt when policyholders stop buying cars or drop their auto insurance.

                                          Whether one likes it or not, we are all in the same boat. Economic prosperity in isolation does not exist. We share our economic prosperity with our neighbors on Wall Street, Main Street, Side Street and Back Street. We are bound to individuals and their families in the smallest tribal villages in the farthest corners of the world.

                                          We must start catalyze the economic recovery now. To defer this fight … the fight to protect and preserve economic stability and prosperity … would be negligent.

                                          The “beggar-thy-neighbor” “race-to-the-bottom” solutions concocted by well-meaning civic leaders in right-to-work states or foreign countries continue the downward spiral for all. The solution to the current economic malaise is not to “steal from Peter to pay Paul”, but to use this moment to shift gears and chart a new course that brings prosperity to America’s Forgotten Middle Class.

                                          We are not through the worst of it yet. The collaterized debt obligations (CDOs) were instrumental in the meltdown of the mortgage market of 2007-2009. Next, the collaterized loan obligations (CLOs) will hit. We have already seen the carcasses of companies bought, required to take out debt, and crippled by oppressive loan repayment obligations and management fees before failing. More unemployment notices will come. Once again, civic leaders will call on the electorate to play safety net and absorb the CLOs when they come due.

                                          The “10-to-4 Plan” is not a panacea. Strictly speaking, it will not stop the CLOs credit crisis. It will do what it can do to re-absorb workers efficiently to re-start the largest, most efficient singular economy in the world, which will enhance economic opportunities abroad.

                                          If our representative leaders truly want a sustained economic recovery, then they should summon forth those champions of non-traditional macroeconomic solutions, like the "10-to-4 Plan", to the December 3rd Jobs Summit.

                                          If invited, I would come.

                                          I was fortunate to live in many places and work with wonderful clients in many industries over the course of my six decades. My goal is to see people walk home to their families knowing that they can afford a good, well-balanced meal, shelter and a little something special for their loved ones because they have purposeful work and a reasonable wage for their efforts. I look forward to passing the torch … called the American Dream … from one generation to the next.

                                          {"commentId":10978670,"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936","authorDomain":"Sunhunterwith2"}
                                            Reply#16 - Tue Dec 1, 2009 6:37 PM EST
                                            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"676096","isPrivate":false}
                                            Leave a Comment:
                                            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                            {"threadId":"676096","contentId":"3266936"}
                                            Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                            Stop TrackingStop Tracking