• Powered by
  • Newsvine:

The Elkhart Project

Stories of struggle and recovery in an American city

 

Stories of struggle and recovery in America: Msnbc.com is focusing long-term coverage on the city of Elkhart, Ind. to provide perspective on the national recession. Follow our ongoing coverage on msnbc.com. Want to share your thoughts on the how the recession is playing out in Elkhart or in your community? Comment on any of the blog posts below or become a blog contributor. Learn how

Full coverage | Why Elkhart? | More about our team

advertisement
{"contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}

Out with the old ...

   

Image: House demolition

John Brecher / msnbc.com

An excavator demolishes a burned house in Elkhart on Monday, Aug. 24. About 95 percent of the debris will be sorted (by material, such as concrete, wood, plastic, steel and asphalt shingle) and recycled, said Chuck Pelley, owner of the excavating company. About five percent of the debris will be too small and mixed up for effective sorting, and goes to a landfill, he said.

The burned-out hulk of a house at 1032 McKinley St. didn’t put up much of a fight Monday when an excavator plunged its shovel through the charred exterior and began spilling its guts across the front yard.

“We’re all so glad it’s gone,“ said next-door neighbor Yolanda Evans, who had been staring at the eyesore since it was left uninhabitable by an early-morning fire on Nov. 20.

The house was leveled courtesy of the federal Neighborhood Stabilization Program, authorized by Congress in the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008. The program is intended to help cities deal with increasing numbers of abandoned and blighted properties left behind by the real estate meltdown.

The city of Elkhart, which received more than $2.25 million through the program, intends to use the money to demolish 60 blighted properties, said Crystal Welsh, the city’s community development director.

It also has formed a consortium with the nearby city of Goshen and the housing assistance agency La Casa to apply for another $6.9 million in funding under the federal stimulus package championed by President Barack Obama. A decision on that application is expected in November.

Elkhart intends to use properties that are cleared for one of three purposes: developing housing for low- to middle-income residents, for sale to neighbors who meet income guidelines or for use as “common areas,” according to a plan filed with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

Many of the lots that the city eventually hopes to develop will be held in a “land bank” -- waiting for the time when the real estate market improves so that it can sell the property.

The elimination of abandoned properties is part of Elkhart’s multi-tiered effort to check the downward economic spiral triggered by the collapse of the RV industry. Click here to read more about why leaders here and in many other cities consider the effort so important.

Chuck Pelley, owner of Pelley Excavating of Niles, Mich., the contractor on the job, said the program doesn’t only benefit neighbors. It also is helping keep his crews busy at a time when construction work has been extremely scarce.

“We’re licensed to do various types of work,” he said as he watched 1032 McKinley come tumbling down. “One of the reasons we did that was to be versatile for times when the economy fluctuates.”

{"contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
{"commentId":9041993,"authorDomain":"andy-1295117"}

An excellent example of tax dollars returned via the trickle down system to stimulate neighborhood improvement and a wise, long-term use of government money.

Investing in communities is never a bad decision, it is just so fraught with bureaucratic red-tape that it rarely occurs without the cost of administering the program exceeding the street level dollar ratio.

{"commentId":9041993,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"andy-1295117"}
    Reply#1 - Tue Aug 25, 2009 8:43 AM EDT
    {"commentId":9042285,"authorDomain":"PSOkiki"}

    I was born in Elkhart and did most of my growing up there even though my home was in Michigan (just 2 miles across the state line.) I'm thrilled to see that such a great community, filled with kind, friendly and caring people, is doing what I've always wished other communities would do ~use land that's just sitting there ugly, abandoned and going to waste. And of course, it's a secret thrill to see the name of the little place where I feel my "real" roots are doing something newsworthy in the BEST possible way....none of that sordid, appalling and horrible "stuff" that we usually see in the news, but some real "feel good" news. Keep up the good work, Elkhart; I'm proud to say that your town is where I come from!

    {"commentId":9042285,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"PSOkiki"}
      Reply#2 - Tue Aug 25, 2009 9:05 AM EDT
      {"commentId":9046145,"authorDomain":"motorcitydoug"}

      Cash for clunkers

      Cash for appliances

      Cash for tearing down houses people could no longer afford

      Cash for unemployment compensation

      Cash for Government Motors

      Cash for Government provided health care

      How about Cash for Stupid Voters!?

      When are you people going to wake up and realize you were hoodwinked by the media into voting for this guy BO? Pretty soon there won't be any workers to pay the taxes this socialist is spending on you, to get your vote. WAKE UP AMERICA!

      {"commentId":9046145,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"motorcitydoug"}
        Reply#3 - Tue Aug 25, 2009 12:26 PM EDT
        {"commentId":9049585,"authorDomain":"vermont251"}

        Demolition can clean up a site, however it can erase history that is irreplaceable. Stabilizing buildings can be a better way to go. Then you can rehab them later. Renovating saves you all the energy that went into the construction of the building originally plus you still have that connection with the past that "lekitty" seems to appreciate.

        {"commentId":9049585,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"vermont251"}
          Reply#4 - Tue Aug 25, 2009 2:45 PM EDT
          {"commentId":9054494,"authorDomain":"kelviin"}

          I agree with Vermont 251 - demolition is always seen as the easiest solution, but isn't always the most economical or preferrable. While I can understand why a community would want to rid themselves of unsafe buildings, the rush to spend money to tear down buildings that could be reused once the economy recovers ultimately costs more in terms of money and the environment.

          In addition, the current economy has saved numerous historic buildings from demolition that would normally be replaced with something new for the sake of having something "new".

          If the government wants to spend its stimulus money wisely, it would look at tax incentives or other ways to encourage local communties and private home owners to reuse, restore and rennovate older properties before encouraging new construction that got us into the current mess.

          What has happened to the housing market is just beginning to happen to the commercial market - how long before we see stretches of empty shopping malls? Preservation and adaptive reuse should be promoted and demolition used only as a last resort.

          {"commentId":9054494,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"kelviin"}
            Reply#5 - Tue Aug 25, 2009 6:02 PM EDT
            {"commentId":9080813,"authorDomain":"megscloset"}

            .....and it took another FEDERAL program to demolish a burned out house? Wonder what the total cost of this demolition was? Can't local people do anything for themselves anymore?

            {"commentId":9080813,"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201","authorDomain":"megscloset"}
              Reply#6 - Wed Aug 26, 2009 5:28 PM EDT
              {"canLink":false,"threadId":"659484","isPrivate":false}
              Leave a Comment:
              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
              {"threadId":"659484","contentId":"3187201"}
              Start TrackingStart Tracking
              Stop TrackingStop Tracking