• Powered by
  • Newsvine:

The Elkhart Project

Stories of struggle and recovery in an American city

 

Stories of struggle and recovery in America: Msnbc.com is focusing long-term coverage on the city of Elkhart, Ind. to provide perspective on the national recession. Follow our ongoing coverage on msnbc.com. Want to share your thoughts on the how the recession is playing out in Elkhart or in your community? Comment on any of the blog posts below or become a blog contributor. Learn how

Full coverage | Why Elkhart? | More about our team

advertisement
{"contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}

Food pantry scrambles to help needy

July 22, 2009: Volunteer Dorothy Miller helps Anival Otero, 23, navigate his first visit to the Middlebury Food Pantry in Middlebury.

Image: Volunteer Dorothy Miller helps Anival Otero, 23, navigate his first visit to the Middlebury Food Pantry in Middlebury.
Volunteer Dorothy Miller helps Anival Otero, 23, navigate his first visit to the Middlebury Food Pantry in Middlebury.

Anival Otero, 23, arrives at the Middlebury Community Food Pantry after running out of options. He drove the 30 miles from Goshen, Ind., after hitting the limit imposed by his local pantry. Nearly all of his $900 July unemployment check - half of what he used to make before being laid off last year by Monaco Trailers - went to bills. He had little left over to feed his three children, ages 2, 3 and 5.

At this pantry, which doesn’t set limits or turn away families, Otero gets the help he needs: $60 worth of groceries, including macaroni and cheese, fresh vegetables and cereal, and vouchers for milk, margarine and eggs to be redeemed at Fork’s County Line Store.

More people from further away are turning to the Middlebury Community Food Pantry, part of the town’s First Mennonite Church. A week before Otero arrived, the pantry set a record, feeding 163 families or a total of 571 people, over a seven-day period.

The volume of visitors has been steadily increasing since last fall when pantry volunteers were accustomed to an average of a dozen families, many of them familiar faces.

"When my pastor first asked me to take over, I had no idea it was going to be like this," says Pam Bingaman, Middlebury's Food Pantry director. "It has just exploded."

The new families standing in line in July were largely Latino families from Goshen, some with eight children in tow, she says. However, throughout the year, first-timers to the pantry have been pouring in from all walks of life, climbing steadily since January, Bingaman says.

On average, 90 percent of those coming to the pantry report being unemployed. Bingaman lost her job as a house inspector last September, just two weeks after she agreed to take over the community pantry's operations, which relies exclusively on volunteers.

"Now it's families who worked their whole lives and weren’t ready for this and their pride wouldn't let them come in here until they had been without for a very long time," she says.

Part of the reason for the increase in traffic is the pantry's own change of policy. In December, Bingaman rounded up the representatives from the eight local churches supporting the pantry to review an unwritten rule that had set a limit on 15 items per family, three times a year. That limit had been in place since the pantry's opening in the 1980s.

In spite of concerns that there might be some who would take advantage of the new policy, Bingaman says everyone at the meeting agreed to not turn families away. "If we have it," she says, "let's share it."

To keep up with the growing demand, the pantry needs to raise $10,000 each month in addition to food donations. The problem is, from time to time, the pantry comes up short.

In the last two newsletters, in bold, red type, the pantry spelled it out: "We are completely out of the following item: CASH." Just three weeks ago, the pantry needed $2,500 to cover expenses, says Bingaman.

So far, help seems to arrive just as it's needed most, Bingaman says. The Middlebury Summer Festival chose the pantry as its cause, and recently, three cows and three pigs were promised from people at the Elkhart County 4-H Fair.

The donations couldn't come at a better time for newcomer Carol Laurette, 61, a retired nurse who lives with her 20-year-grandson, his girlfriend and son in Edwardsburg, Mich. Her son, who works as a receiver in the car industry, is the only person in the house who holds a job, she says.

"They laid people off last Friday and they're going to lay some people off this Friday - he might be next," she says. "I could really use the help."

{"contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
{"commentId":8486600,"authorDomain":"williamlknight"}

So, Anival Otero presumably one of the hundreds of undocumented {illegal} workers the RV industry hired because "nobody wants to do these jobs" of course the real answer is that they wanted to exploit the cheap labor option.

Now Anival O, drives 120 miles RT to get more freebies from bighearted Elkhart. You can bet he's visited with more than just his local foodbank. He probably has their locations on his GPS in his SUV. Shouldn't poor ole Anival use his gas money to look for a job or better yet go back to Mexico.

{"commentId":8486600,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"williamlknight"}
    Reply#1 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 12:48 PM EDT
    {"commentId":8489711,"authorDomain":"roliro123"}

    I doubt that the trailer factory that Anival worked for hired illegals. If you, Will I Am, had a family and you were desparate to feed them, I would hope that you would drive the 75 or so roundtrip miles he did since I'm sure you would be as responsible a parent as he.

    {"commentId":8489711,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"roliro123"}
      #1.1 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 2:56 PM EDT
      {"commentId":8501259,"authorDomain":"browneyes"}

      Will I Am...that is truly an ugly approach to have in a time that the entire country and millions of people, including all races, are unemployed. I lost my job in December and even though I haven't had to use a food bank or government help, I feel for those that do. You should probably pray that's not you someday in the near future...unemployed and wondering how in the hell you are going to make it...think before you waste your time speaking.

      {"commentId":8501259,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"browneyes"}
      • 1 vote
      #1.2 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 6:53 AM EDT
      {"commentId":8504538,"authorDomain":"rbracker-2"}

      Will I am,

      You obviously can't add. Its 30 miles he drove from Goshen to Middlebury. That make's a round trip . . .60 miles. Other than that, Monoco used to be one of the best places to work in Elkhart county. Great benefits and their product line was diversified enough that you could count on keeping you job. That was in the past though. I used to be a bleeding heart liberal. That was in the past as well. Living in Elkhart since the influx of the illegals has destroyed my sense of fair play for others. It began when my brother lost his job at Johnson Controls when they began shipping all of their stuff to Mexico. It was really funny though becasue they would have to bring it back to Goshen to be reworked because so many of the parts were bad. My sister-in-law lost her job at Bayer when they left town for cheaper labor elsewhere. My question again is though, why is the Elkhart Truth and MSN focusing on a "latino" family? There are more people out of work here than the illegals. Many of the unemployed in Elkhart county aren't the newly arrived illegals. They are people whose parents, grandparents and even great grandparents worked for and retired from the same companies that are now letting them go. There are a lot of older people who need the help just as bad if not worse with the rising cost of medicine and health care. To those illegal aliens who can't find work here...go home. Its where all of the money you made here in the US is so just go home.

      {"commentId":8504538,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"rbracker-2"}
        #1.3 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:12 AM EDT
        {"commentId":8508745,"authorDomain":"stephanied"}

        Just because he is hispanic, doesn't make him illegal. Even if he was, where is your compassion for another human being that is struggling to take care of his family?!? Many people are suffering from the economy right now. These people could use your prayers more than your bigetry. Although I believe people should be here legally, I don't want to see anyone suffering from this economy. Especially the innocent children that can't do anything to change their unfortunate situation.

        {"commentId":8508745,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"stephanied"}
          #1.4 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 12:41 PM EDT
          Reply
          {"commentId":8487115,"authorDomain":"jaxon98"}

          It does not matter where he is from, what matters is the food pantry needs help. There are a lot of US citizen in line for food these days not by there own choice.

          {"commentId":8487115,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"jaxon98"}
            Reply#2 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:10 PM EDT
            {"commentId":8488286,"authorDomain":"bigdaddypancakes"}

            Will "I" Am, you need to get your thinking out of the stone ages. Don't you get it? It does not matter what color, race or nationality you are we are all brothers & sisters here on this big blue planet whether you like or not! This article sheds light on a great need we all have in our own communitys. Did you miss the message? "So far, help seems to arrive just as it's needed most" (God will provide) and "When my pastor first asked me to take over, I had no idea it was going to be like this," says Pam Bingaman, Middlebury's Food Pantry director. "It has just exploded." God never puts us in places or situations that we can't handle. It's great too see his work passed through this message. One more thing, will I am, when you usaully assume something you usaully make a ass out of your self.

            {"commentId":8488286,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"bigdaddypancakes"}
              Reply#3 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:59 PM EDT
              {"commentId":8507008,"authorDomain":"robyn-4"}

              You are right. I is about doing God's work. No more, no less. I work at a food pantry and the need is great. It doesn't matter who it is, they need help. It's not our place to judge.

              {"commentId":8507008,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"robyn-4"}
                #3.1 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 11:37 AM EDT
                Reply
                {"commentId":8491104,"authorDomain":"goshenite"}

                will_i_am - you make the mistake that many make by starting from the assumption that Anival is illegal. The other possibilites are: (1) he is not actually Hispanic, even though the name sounds like he could be, (2) he is Hispanic, and a citizen, (3) he is Hispanic, but documented, (4) he is specifically Puerto Rican, and has always been a citizen. All of those are very possible.

                There have been many Hispanics doing "the jobs no one else will do," picking fruit, working in slaughter houses, being busboys, etc. This is not the case in the RV factories. I have never heard it suggested that anyone working there earns less than anyone else because the employer sees "cheap labor." All sorts of people work there. Hispanics are known as hard workers. I believe they earn a fair wage in the factories.

                By the way, Goshen and Middlebury are actually about 12 miles apart.

                {"commentId":8491104,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"goshenite"}
                • 1 vote
                Reply#4 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 3:54 PM EDT
                {"commentId":8496598,"authorDomain":"bill-stull"}

                Are you trying to say nobody picked crops, worked in slaughter houses or were busboys. You are trying to say this country was built by hispanics. You must be trying to rewrite history. My ancestors settled, counquered and built it. All kinds of people merged into one people.

                {"commentId":8496598,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"bill-stull"}
                  #4.1 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:47 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":8509196,"authorDomain":"stephanied"}

                  Nothing was said about hispanics building this country. In all honesty this country was founded by immigrants, period. Also, I believe we are talking about the present not the past. Currently we see more hispanics picking fruit, working in slaughter houses and being busing tables.

                  {"commentId":8509196,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"stephanied"}
                    #4.2 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 12:56 PM EDT
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":8491612,"authorDomain":"williamlknight"}

                    Enough from the Elkhart crowd. There have been many stories written about the huge influx of illegals working in that industry. You all seem so intimately knowledgable about this unfortunate thrown out of work. I by the way, didn't say he traveled 60 miles to get food the article mentioned that fact.

                    {"commentId":8491612,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"williamlknight"}
                      Reply#5 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 4:15 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":8509252,"authorDomain":"stephanied"}

                      You're right...you said 120 miles!

                      {"commentId":8509252,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"stephanied"}
                        #5.1 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 12:58 PM EDT
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":8496231,"authorDomain":"1teacher"}

                        I am a volunteer at a food pantry and I did this because I wanted to give back to my community. I feel that we have lived in such abundance that we have forgotten how to give.

                        I found myself unemployed not hungry or homeless because my husband has a job that can provide for us,THANK GOD FOR FOR HIM AND FOR HIS JOB!!!!

                        I really searched my heart at what I should do during this time that jobs are scarce....I was depressed and really not feeling good about myself. I am a certified teacher in California and if you read or listen to the news, we are in a predicament.

                        For the person who feels that illegals are draining our economy and food pantries....I hope that you don't ever lose your job and have to go through this ordeal. No one is guaranteed anything in his life.....You may be find yourself at a food pantry and if you do I guarantee the volunteers at the pantry will accept and help you and try to lift your spirits....We see the stress, the worry and imbarrassment in peoples faces. I have not met one person i.e. black, white hispanic, asian, russian and the list goes on who enjoys coming to ask for free food .

                        {"commentId":8496231,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"1teacher"}
                          Reply#6 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:25 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":8498928,"authorDomain":"sanmuga"}

                          We've got to appreciate Will_i_am...

                          He/she takes on the name of one of the most admired musicians in the world who has shown so much love and care for the suffering in the world, and yet can have the desperate need for love and care himself/herself.

                          How else can anyone explain to me why he/she would want to take so much effort to run down the sincere efforts of a community organisation to help those affected by the downturn by making it about race?

                          {"commentId":8498928,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"sanmuga"}
                            Reply#7 - Tue Jul 28, 2009 11:36 PM EDT
                            {"commentId":8499897,"authorDomain":"ahunkacheese"}

                            will_i_am... what an ignorant fool. I think you like to see your name in print or hear yourself talk so to speak. I now live in the deep south but come from the Elkhart area. Most of my family lives there still & they are having hard times brother. The area is so heavily invested in the RV industry & that's not the worker's fault. When that industry goes down everything else follows... the domino effect. Even the part time jobs students normally do are being taken by adults trying to make ends meet 'til there are no jobs left. Imagine working hard all your life & one day the job disappears & there is not another to be had no matter how hard you'll work, how good you are at it, or what you know how to do. Then goes your house & all you've worked for 'til the only thing left is your pride & idiots like you would take that too. You attempt to divert attention from the real issue. This story is not about illegals it's about a community struggling to survive & they're doing it by helping each other. I doubt you know anything about that. I bet you sit in front of your computer all day whining to the world about things you know nothing about because the people who know you have already had enough of it & quit listening long ago. They're probably long gone. Maybe that's why you're so miserable & small minded. So sad, but that's your doing. I also think whatever smart comment you have to make back to me will only serve to show I hit a nerve. And by the way... we're not mad... we're all just laughing at you.

                            {"commentId":8499897,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"ahunkacheese"}
                              Reply#8 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 1:40 AM EDT
                              {"commentId":8500034,"authorDomain":"Chip87"}

                              Will_I_Am and others....

                              There was a newspaper article in one of the Chicago papers (Southtown, Tribune, Sun Times, etc.) about many Amish workers who worked in the RV industry in places like Indiana and other neighboring states. Many of these Amish got laid off over the past few years, and even more had to do things they normally don't, such as drive a vehicle to find work farther away from home. Life can be difficult for anyone. It doesn't matter where you're from or where you are now or HOW LONG you've been there. Are the Amish illegal? No. Undocumented? Largely. Chew on that for a while, and ask yourself and your historic ancestors of the United States of America why should you have no sympathy for others. That failing take a lesson from the Amish as well. Perhaps they don't like recent immigrants either, but they don't complain on the Internet, anonymously or otherwise. If you have nothing nice to say, say nothing at all.

                              I encourage anyone else to search for that news article before making assumptions about particular groups and industry.

                              {"commentId":8500034,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"Chip87"}
                                Reply#9 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 2:01 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":8504853,"authorDomain":"rbracker-2"}

                                Chip-

                                The illegal aliens are NOT recent immigrants. They are in this country because they broke the law. Not exactly the kind of people I want as my next door neighbor. You don't know much about the Amish either. They are not largely undocumented. The Amish that my mother worked with all had birth certificates and went to school. At least to the eighth grade. They go to the English hospitals when they are ill, have babies there and some of them have driver's licenses. They have to get special permission form their bishop and the community they live in. But it can be done. If you want to learn about the Amish sometime, come to Elkhart County. We have plenty and the Amish here are very nice.

                                {"commentId":8504853,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"rbracker-2"}
                                  #9.1 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:24 AM EDT
                                  Reply
                                  {"commentId":8500722,"authorDomain":"clydelover"}

                                  Time to start dumpster diving folks. I've been doing it since May at supermarket dumpsters and I'm eating better now than I was before I was laid off. Tho most supermarkets have compactors that are impossible to access... there are some medium and small sized markets that use regular dumpsters... You'll be amazed how much usable food they throw away every day because the "use by date" is up or a lable is missing, fruit or veggies have a small imperfection, or a can is dented. It's perfectly legal and because of the Emerson, Good Samaritan food donation act, you might even be able to convince those stores that have compactors to donate such stuff to your local food pantry. Good luck all.

                                  {"commentId":8500722,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"clydelover"}
                                    Reply#10 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 4:26 AM EDT
                                    {"commentId":8505392,"authorDomain":"decelloc"}

                                    Why should I be concerned because some people insist on breeding 8 new humans on this planet and expect other people to feed them?

                                    We really need to understand that it's not a lack of resources that plagues this country, but the lack of breeding laws.

                                    {"commentId":8505392,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"decelloc"}
                                      Reply#11 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:44 AM EDT
                                      {"commentId":8507533,"authorDomain":"dee1968"}

                                      I think Mr. "I Am" is missing the point all together. The RV industry is in trouble because the RV's are luxury item NOT a necessity. Many people from all walks of life are losing their jobs from the top on down. When luxury items stop selling it is an indication that even people who are typically secure who usually have a large amount of disposal income are watching their dollars. Lets face it the RVing crowd is typically white. All is not well in anyone's financial world white, black, hispanic etc. We are all in this together but Mr. "I Am" is choosing to show his hatred and ignorance by saying it is a racial and or immigrant issue. I have lived in Indiana and in fact had work down my many companies who hire LEGAL hispanic workers. I was very impressed with their ambitiousness and their how detailed they were with their work. Something tells me where ever Mr. "I am" works he is a whiner and complainer and everybody is to blame for his shortcomings. It would never occur to him to reach out to help someone else because he too busy caught up in being a victim of his on stupidity.

                                      {"commentId":8507533,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"dee1968"}
                                        Reply#12 - Wed Jul 29, 2009 11:58 AM EDT
                                        {"commentId":8650347,"authorDomain":"crickethig"}

                                        I want to see Comm. goverment food to show up on our shelfs all across America in food pantry The gov. packages billions of dollars worth of meat cheese flour powder milk, honey,butter it is time to stop sending it to other countrys and gave to us that worked to pay for it we need it here now in every state. I know different states get some of it the we need more that is laying rotting in storage buildings and being gave to eveybody but good old usa.

                                        {"commentId":8650347,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"crickethig"}
                                          Reply#13 - Wed Aug 5, 2009 8:36 PM EDT
                                          {"commentId":8678890,"authorDomain":"loie67"}

                                          Please people don't take this wrong is not time to talk politics and my hart is with you folks. When i saw President Obama speech on the Rv factory I ask myself where's is Sarah Palin and Jonh Mckain? where? they FORGOT! the people from Indiana. Now the man you vote Against and his last name is Obama. is coming back to continue his promise of bring jobs to your town. I hope" this teach a big lesson to your state. you people khowing that the Bush administration screw you state and the world vote Republican again anyway. you people should be a shame. WHERE IS SARAH PALIN? AND JOHN? where?

                                          {"commentId":8678890,"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889","authorDomain":"loie67"}
                                            Reply#14 - Thu Aug 6, 2009 11:54 PM EDT
                                            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"636919","isPrivate":false}
                                            Leave a Comment:
                                            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                            {"threadId":"636919","contentId":"3076889"}
                                            Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                            Stop TrackingStop Tracking