• Powered by
  • Newsvine:

 

 

Stories of struggle and recovery in America: Msnbc.com is focusing long-term coverage on the city of Elkhart, Ind. to provide perspective on the national recession. Follow our ongoing coverage on msnbc.com. Want to share your thoughts on the how the recession is playing out in Elkhart or in your community? Comment on any of the blog posts below or become a blog contributor. Learn how

Full coverage | Why Elkhart? | More about our team

Follow this project via ...
advertisement
{"contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}

Cobbler taps into spirit of thriftiness

Image: Randy Bailey, owner of Harold's Shoe Repair

Jim Seida / msnbc.com
"People have less money; they're getting things fixed and they're learning why their grandparents never threw anything away," says Randy Bailey, owner of Harold's Shoe Repair in downtown Elkhart.

It's obvious that Randy Bailey cares about his customers. When they bring him their shoes, purses, belts or baseball gloves that are worn, faded, broken or chewed by a dog, he listens carefully to what they need and quickly gets to work on the repair, usually finishing the job in a day or two.

Bailey, 56, is the owner of Harold's Shoe Repair, which occupies an old, small building on South Main Street, just south of the railroad tracks in Elkhart. There's little retail display space in the shop, which is redolent of rubber cement, but what little exists is filled by polish, laces, shoehorns and leather treatments. Shelves of repaired and resoled shoes behind the counter await their owners as Bailey and two part-time employees busily work on more-recent arrivals.

"We're up about 15 percent this year," Bailey says. "People have less money; they're getting things fixed and they're learning why their grandparents never threw anything away. Because they went through the Great Depression and they didn't have it."

Bailey, who bought the business in 2006, occupies another niche in the community, serving more than 400 customers with special orthopedic needs.

"They bring in a prescription and we fill it," says Bailey. "We do what we call flares, which makes the shoe wider for more stability. We do wedges, which changes the angle of the foot to relieve pain in some people. We can do build-ups, which is for leg length discrepancy… When your feet hurt it makes it hard to do a lot of things."

Bailey knows first-hand about different kinds of pain.

In November 1993, he says he tried to commit suicide by jumping off of a 35-foot-high tower at a nearby park.

"I was working, I had been for five years, as an assistant manager at a convenience store and it just started getting too stressful for me and I'm not a person that -- at that time at least -- … reached out to other people. It was just too big for me to handle and I jumped off the observation tower at Oxbow Park. I was paranoid for a few years before that, and depression and paranoia kind of feed off each other. And when you think there's a way that you can stop the hurting it seems more and more attractive."

The plunge left Bailey with crushed heels, a broken leg, a hole in his right ankle and compression fractures in two vertebrae. He underwent two surgeries during two months of hospitalization and a third two months later.

Sixteen years later, the bones in his right foot are fused and misshapen. With his heel on the floor, he can only lift his toes a quarter inch. He usually works in his socks, even though the floor is pretty dirty and has shoe tacks on it. "It's more comfortable" he says.

Image: Randy Bailey, owner of Harold's Shoe Repair

Jim Seida / msnbc.com
Randy Bailey uses a hammer and brass tacks to attach new heels to a pair of women's shoes.

A pair of orthopedic shoes costs him about $1,000, so between fixing his customers' shoes, Bailey is working to make a pair for himself.

The experience has changed Bailey's outlook. "Before I felt like I always had to keep my feelings inside, not talk with other people, not reach out to them," he said. "I was very shy. I found that it helps a lot to talk to other people. Just the fact that I can come to work and have a place to go to keep myself occupied, that can do a lot to help keep depression away."

Bailey recently bought a brick building two blocks down the street that, at more than 7,000 square feet, is four times the size of his current shop. He's planning on moving on July 1 and says he won't miss a day of being open for his customers.

"I try to do the best I can to help people with their foot problems," Bailey says. "That's the kind of thing that really makes somebody feel good …when people say, 'You really helped me.' That's really what I'm in it for."

{"contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
{"commentId":7558629,"authorDomain":"kazmark"}

A great story. I am a GED teacher and work in retail, and see depressed people all the time. People feel they are on an island without support from their surroundings. Randy keep up the good work and keep people on their feet. My mother had painful feet for most of her life and her orthopedic shoes saved her sanity.

{"commentId":7558629,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"kazmark"}
    Reply#1 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 11:53 AM EDT
    {"commentId":7560664,"authorDomain":"hikingstick"}

    I understand cobblers are becoming extremely rare in our society. I have wide feet, and often have a hard time finding comfortable shoes. If I wanted to study to become a cobbler, how would I go about doing that? Are any cobblers out there taking apprentices, or are there any cobbler training programs?

    {"commentId":7560664,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"hikingstick"}
    • 1 vote
    Reply#2 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 1:07 PM EDT
    Reply
    {"commentId":7561752,"authorDomain":"belen2310"}
    BelénDeleted
    {"commentId":7561785,"authorDomain":"melodye-pease"}

    We have a shoe cobbler here in New Baltimore/Chesterfield Michigan. Steve reapairs just about anything from shoes to saddle repair and all kinds of leather. Suit cases and boat covers and everything else. Yes it is a dieing art, but maybe it wil have a big come back now. We are so lucky to have him here in our town

    {"commentId":7561785,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"melodye-pease"}
    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 1:47 PM EDT
    {"commentId":7562322,"authorDomain":"rjchief"}

    I recently retired from the shoe repair trade after 25 years. I learned by on-the-job training. That seems to be the best way to teach and learn the trade. You have to learn by doing, not reading. Tearing down, sanding, trimming, welting, using the McCay and curved needle stitchers and patchers all require time to learn to do professional quality work. You'll mess up plenty of stuff, but there's a lot of junk stuff out there to practice on in any shop. For a person with the aptitude to learn the trade, I'd say you need a minimum of 18 months before you get comfortable enough doing bench and machine work to be considered a "journeyman" cobbler. There was a school at Oklahoma State University that taught shoe, boot and saddle repair and while it gives you some practice on basic and necessary skills, it's not the same as working in a "live" shop. And it's not dull, I've worked on some weird stuff. The strangest was a hot tamale machine a guy wanted me to repair. It wasn't a shoe or purse, but what the hell. Mostly I had a good time and made a good living and after all years and customers that passed thru my doors, I only had to tell 4 or 5 to get the hell out and don't come back.

    {"commentId":7562322,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"rjchief"}
    • 1 vote
    Reply#5 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 2:05 PM EDT
    {"commentId":7562601,"authorDomain":"mawmawm"}

    My mother was a shoe cobbler! I would go to work with her . I learned to do many repairs-even half-sole shoes! She wouldn't let me run the big sewing machine stitchers. They were dangerous. The best thing I got out of going to work with her-was learning to be sociable, tactful, and just interested in people. I wouldn't take anything for the experience. This was in Jasper, Alabama. Also, I have relatives in Elkhart Indiana! Hello to all Swindles there!

    {"commentId":7562601,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"mawmawm"}
      Reply#6 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 2:15 PM EDT
      {"commentId":7562755,"authorDomain":"freshesttomato"}

      I've always used cobblers. When you spend 100. on a pair of shoes or a purse, or even if you spent 10. on them, when you like something and don't want to part with it, cobblers can make them almost new again. Re-sole, re-heel, dye, fix straps, cover holes, they're wonderful. I wish this man well and know that he is no doubt appreciated by his customers as much as he appreciates them.

      {"commentId":7562755,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"freshesttomato"}
        Reply#7 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 2:20 PM EDT
        {"commentId":7563588,"authorDomain":"dave98503"}

        why talk about the depression all the time?what about the recession of 1996 ? I remember that being very rough. as for the depression...believe me...there were many rich people living back then, especially in the entertainment and other business...people always needed food also. I can't recall a single story about anyone speaking about the depression personally...and people still had jobs although it was rough for some. I guess it got more publicity because of the widespread use of cameras and improvements in photographic technology since the last depression between somewhere around the 1870s to late 1880s i believe.

        {"commentId":7563588,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"dave98503"}
          Reply#8 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 2:49 PM EDT
          {"commentId":7564880,"authorDomain":"Phillytwo"}

          I suppose it was easier in the 30's depression; everyone grew a garden. Now most people are city dwellers and wouldn't know a garden if they stepped in it. People didn't have much then; no TV, no refrigerators, no indoor plumbing many times, not everyone had a car or phone. I am poor now, but I have cable, a car, indoor plumbing, etc. Ah for the good old days. Now you can say you heard it from the horse's mouth.

          {"commentId":7564880,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"Phillytwo"}
            #8.1 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 3:39 PM EDT
            Reply
            {"commentId":7567622,"authorDomain":"ack"}

            Really good story.

            {"commentId":7567622,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"ack"}
              Reply#9 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 5:17 PM EDT
              {"commentId":7569110,"authorDomain":"karen-scott"}

              An inspirational story. We all have our story and to pick yourself up and succeed is a true inspiration. What a happy story. We need more of these.

              {"commentId":7569110,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"karen-scott"}
                Reply#10 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 6:27 PM EDT
                {"commentId":7569963,"authorDomain":"sparky46514"}

                I use his services and am very happy with his work.BTW I am an IBEW 153 member in the South Bend/Mishawaka/Elkhart area.

                {"commentId":7569963,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"sparky46514"}
                  Reply#11 - Wed Jun 10, 2009 7:16 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7575012,"authorDomain":"bonbon823"}

                  This article sure brought back memories for me. My father repaired shoes for nearly 50 years before old age put an end to his career. Some of my earliest memories are of his shop; the smell of the rubber cement, the shoe dye, the smoky-leathery odor when he ground down soles on his finisher machine. This machine was huge; it took up an entire wall of the shop. He had a very old Singer sewing machine that he used for certain jobs; I learned to sew doll clothes on it. I was also sure that this profession was doomed. It's nice to see it being revived again.

                  {"commentId":7575012,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"bonbon823"}
                    Reply#12 - Thu Jun 11, 2009 1:18 AM EDT
                    {"commentId":7575633,"authorDomain":"crgaush"}

                    I well remember the old shoe shops in town. I was born in Novemebr of 1929 and we used the showmaker all the time. The smell of the glue and leather brings back memories. Best wishes to this gentleman and his business.

                    {"commentId":7575633,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"crgaush"}
                      Reply#13 - Thu Jun 11, 2009 2:42 AM EDT
                      {"commentId":7586590,"authorDomain":"Constitutionalpatriot"}

                      Nick Giacobelli, on Main Streeet in the town of Girard, Pennsylvania, does some of the best shoe work I've ever seen. I've been taking shoes to him for more than 20 years now. There is another pair of gentlemen in the city of Erie, PA, on West 9th street, who also do excellent work.

                      I sure as hell hope that some enterprising younger people decide that the shoe repair business is worth getting into, because I don't know what I'd do without either of these businesses........

                      {"commentId":7586590,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"Constitutionalpatriot"}
                        Reply#14 - Thu Jun 11, 2009 3:47 PM EDT
                        {"commentId":7607293,"authorDomain":"dpnova"}

                        I discovered the cobbler business when I started looking for a dressage boot (horse riding boots) that fit, however, finding a cobbler that would touch them is another story. If you'd be willing to fix, make adjustments or custom make these boots, I bet you'd have a niche market that would flock to you. My problem is that I'm short and muscular....manufacturers will only mass produce the tall slender build. I've been around the block trying to find something that works for me....know I just use half chaps whenever possible. Still haven't solved my problem with the dressage boot.

                        P.S. Aren't Amish communities big into horses? It should be so hard for this business to tap in and understand this market....just a thought.

                        {"commentId":7607293,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"dpnova"}
                          Reply#15 - Fri Jun 12, 2009 12:57 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":7622740,"authorDomain":"fwhaskew"}

                          I was four years old and had worn out the soles of my shoes. We were neither poor nor well off, just frugal and industrious as were most in 1934 England (UK that is) Dad, a Motor Mechanic by trade, made a marvellous job of hand stitching new soles, soaking and forming the leather in the fashion of the best practice only to discover he had been mis-sold on the leather quality so that the soles shrank. Damage was to such an extent that the shoes were ruined. Came 1944, I was 14 and my shoes were in need of repair. Dad was busy with a full work schedule, Home Guard, Works and Street fire- watching duties so, remembering as I had seen done 10 years earlier I set about doing my own repair. Of course there was room for improvement and that came over the years, until modern shoe manufacturing practice and materials took overabout twenty years ago. I have never employed a shoe-mender but have had many interresting conversations with them over the years.The greater their skills, the more willingly would they share their knowledge , so I found.

                          {"commentId":7622740,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"fwhaskew"}
                            Reply#16 - Sat Jun 13, 2009 5:42 AM EDT
                            {"commentId":7626284,"authorDomain":"pwm11"}

                            Life always comes full circle. It's nice to see the shoe repair business is still alive and kicking. I would like to see more shoe shine boys, but that may be a stretch. Keep your head up, Elkhart, you're not alone!

                            {"commentId":7626284,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"pwm11"}
                              Reply#17 - Sat Jun 13, 2009 1:22 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":7635578,"authorDomain":"eileenk847"}

                              God bless his heart! I love his story. He provides a service we all still need and want. The fact that his shop is on MAIN STREET really makes me smile too. When I lived in another city years ago I frequented a shoe repair man who repaired all of my high heels and any leather handbag that needed attention. I visited his shop for man years and loved to look around while I waited. Thanks for the inspirational story. I wish him health and prosperity.

                              {"commentId":7635578,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"eileenk847"}
                                Reply#18 - Sun Jun 14, 2009 9:04 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":7635648,"authorDomain":"Rixar13"}

                                This reminds me of the decline of the shoe industry in Maine where I lived for many years.

                                "People have less money; they're getting things fixed and they're learning why their grandparents never threw anything away," says Randy Bailey, owner of Harold's Shoe Repair in downtown Elkhart. It's obvious that Randy Bailey cares about his customers.

                                This story is distressing but as I learned as the University of Maine graduate Business, there is a new opportunity. Expanding business could not go on forever with the globalization of our communities, we need to keep our business closer to home.

                                {"commentId":7635648,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"Rixar13"}
                                  Reply#19 - Sun Jun 14, 2009 9:15 AM EDT
                                  {"commentId":7654368,"authorDomain":"cgeller2"}

                                  tHIS IS THE KIND OF NEWS I WANT TO READ ABOUT! Thanks to this man- thanks to whoever decided to write about him--more please!

                                  {"commentId":7654368,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"cgeller2"}
                                    Reply#20 - Mon Jun 15, 2009 2:03 PM EDT
                                    {"commentId":7655780,"authorDomain":"bobket"}

                                    corny as it sounds he turned lemons into lemonade

                                    {"commentId":7655780,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"bobket"}
                                      Reply#21 - Mon Jun 15, 2009 3:06 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":7657693,"authorDomain":"michaelbme"}

                                      I am truly inspired by this man's story. Keep up the good work!

                                      {"commentId":7657693,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"michaelbme"}
                                        Reply#22 - Mon Jun 15, 2009 4:39 PM EDT
                                        {"commentId":7662354,"authorDomain":"race-9togo"}

                                        If you look carefully, you will find that cobblers are not a rare as you think. It is just that the mass-production of cheap footwear has made a lot of their work go away. But for anyone who has paid more than $60.00 for footwear that doesn't last more than two years, a cobbler is a neccessary part of life!

                                        I have been wearing the same pair of comfortable walking shoes for 20 years. Re-soled and repaired by a cobbler.

                                        This is a great story.

                                        {"commentId":7662354,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"race-9togo"}
                                          Reply#23 - Mon Jun 15, 2009 9:26 PM EDT
                                          {"commentId":7691895,"authorDomain":"nakeddave"}

                                          I'm glad this man found some peace, it's sad that nobody noticed how troubled he was to begin with, but thankfully living through the experience it seems he learned something important: HE HAS WORTH, he is important. Not just to other people, to himself. Randy rocks!

                                           

                                          Personally I have used cobblers for years. There is a good one in center city Philadelphia though being there he has raised his prices higher than some discount shoes, and unfortunatly the quality has slipped. Anyone know a good shoe repair in Philly?

                                          {"commentId":7691895,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"nakeddave"}
                                            Reply#24 - Wed Jun 17, 2009 9:00 AM EDT
                                            {"commentId":7695668,"authorDomain":"cheekylilchatter"}

                                            We have a shoe repair business in town, but I have not been in. We usually bought cheap shoes when we were younger and if they fell to disrepair, we wore them anyways. thats what breadsacks were for! lol. I wonder tho if they could help me with getting my shoes more comfortable. I wear a 10.5 wide in womens and those are hard to come by. So they are always too small or too big.

                                            I'm glad they had a 'good news' story, Im tired of all the depressing stuff. Don't reporters think that maybe all the dire news are making people depressed and they may feel an urge to jump just as he?

                                            {"commentId":7695668,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"cheekylilchatter"}
                                              Reply#25 - Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:54 AM EDT
                                              {"commentId":7777104,"authorDomain":"winsettz"}

                                              In Cali, I don't know if I'd seen one before.

                                              I think at least in Cali it might partially be the lack of knowledge (or, to put it bluntly, ignorance) about the kinds of work cobblers do today. I didn't think they did regular running shoes and handbags as well; that's actually kind of new and interesting. I think I will actually check it out the directories for one...you know, just in case.

                                              {"commentId":7777104,"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127","authorDomain":"winsettz"}
                                                Reply#26 - Mon Jun 22, 2009 6:45 AM EDT
                                                {"canLink":false,"threadId":"599855","isPrivate":false}
                                                Leave a Comment:
                                                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                                {"threadId":"599855","contentId":"2910127"}
                                                Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                                Stop TrackingStop Tracking