• Powered by
  • Newsvine:

 

 

Stories of struggle and recovery in America: Msnbc.com is focusing long-term coverage on the city of Elkhart, Ind. to provide perspective on the national recession. Follow our ongoing coverage on msnbc.com. Want to share your thoughts on the how the recession is playing out in Elkhart or in your community? Comment on any of the blog posts below or become a blog contributor. Learn how

Full coverage | Why Elkhart? | More about our team

Follow this project via ...
advertisement
{"contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}

Student wins free car in perfect attendance raffle

Image: raffle car
Courtesy of Deb Keller
Brittany Elsworth, a freshman at Elkhart Memorial High School, and school Principal Mark Tobolski stand next to a 2002 Dodge Stratus donated by Lochmandy motors, a car dealership in Elkhart. Elsworth won a raffle for students with perfect attendance. While they let her pose with the car, Elsworth wasn't allowed to drive it off the lawn as she's not yet old enough to have her driver's license.

We've written lately about the challenges facing Elkhart high school students in these tough economic times (and you'll be meeting some of those students and hearing their stories next week.) But in the meantime, how about some good news about a generous reward for a great accomplishment?

Brittany Elsworth, a freshman at Elkhart Memorial High School, learned last week that good attendance pays off when she won a car at a raffle for 153 students who had perfect or almost-perfect records.

"I just thought I would win it, told my friends I would probably win it, and I guess I did!" an excited Elsworth told local TV station WSBT. Elsworth won't be able to drive her prize right away. She can't get her learner's permit for at least a year and will temporarily rely on her brother to chauffeur her around.

"We feel very lucky to be able to have something like this," Principal Mark Tobolski said of the special drawing. Other prizes included gift certificates and money. Elkhart's Central High School had a similar annual raffle, but its sponsor backed out this year because of the tough business climate.

Generous townsfolk and others from far away have stepped up to help students attend the senior prom and have caps and gowns for graduation ceremony, and the Lochmandy dealership came through with the grandest of prizes, tough times or no.

Such acts of generosity are likely to be rarer across the country when Chrysler and GM close nearly 2,000 U.S. dealerships. Car dealerships tend to be very active in their communities – helping sponsor everything from Little League to libraries, rodeos to road races. In return for their donations, the businesses get their names printed on jerseys, programs and signs, and customers are often happy to repay that generosity when it's time to buy new vehicles.

Douglas Graft, one of the owners of a Chrysler dealership in Scottdale, Pa., told the Associated Press recently that his company had already reduced its charitable activities because of the recession and poor sales.

Already, funding for good causes can be hard to come by.

Ashley Alexander, a student at Elkhart's Central High School , for example, qualified for a national event sponsored by Business Professionals of America, an organization that prepares students for careers in business and the IT field. But she and her fellow club members have had a difficult time raising funds to attend.

"There aren't any club funds in reserve from previous years to send the girls and one chaperone," said Anna Alexander, her mother. "These girls have worked hard to get to nationals and it is an honor to go. With Elkhart being the national focus for months the girls want to represent Elkhart in a positive way."

Are you concerned that the closure of one or more local car dealerships will adversely impact your community? What alternatives could schools and other organizations explore as sources for charitable giving? Share your thoughts by leaving a comment below.

{"contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"elkhartprojectblog"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3
{"commentId":7304719,"authorDomain":"winsettz"}

Perfect attendance, whoopee. Not grades? Not community service? Just...showing up every day?

{"commentId":7304719,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"winsettz"}
  • 5 votes
Reply#1 - Wed May 27, 2009 9:43 AM EDT
{"commentId":7306211,"authorDomain":"iofferkicks001"}
vkalyDeleted
{"commentId":7316898,"authorDomain":"mail-62"}

Public school funding is exponential to student attendance--- It is a wonder all schools don't follow suit; even without a donor.

Another prime example of rewarding people for what was once considered a responsibility.

{"commentId":7316898,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"mail-62"}
  • 2 votes
#1.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 7:04 PM EDT
{"commentId":7324289,"authorDomain":"sgarman"}

If it was your kid I bet you wouldnt be complaining. Maybe the family needs a car? Maybe they'll "Do the right thing" and give the car back...would that make you happy? Alot of people acomplish the sme feat everyday and no one cares. Kudos to Lachmandy Motors for caring.

{"commentId":7324289,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"sgarman"}
    #1.3 - Thu May 28, 2009 9:11 AM EDT
    {"commentId":7326963,"authorDomain":"laurensdelange"}

    In this world attendance is more important then results!

    I would give the car to the student where the attendance/results ratio is highest, because that truly deserves a price.

    {"commentId":7326963,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"laurensdelange"}
      #1.4 - Thu May 28, 2009 11:35 AM EDT
      {"commentId":7329153,"authorDomain":"deandommer"}

      Why do people need to analynize who or what is the fairest way to win the car. Isn't it the dealership's privilege to offer a free gift to whomever they choose? This has become a crazy world. Even an act of kindness to the community gets critics , or more appropiately cynics, who don't get it. Good for the dealership, good for the school, good for the community. Do the math!

      {"commentId":7329153,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"deandommer"}
      • 2 votes
      #1.5 - Thu May 28, 2009 1:13 PM EDT
      Reply
      {"commentId":7305176,"authorDomain":"sarah-toney"}

      I love a contest that punishes kids for getting sick. Lovely. Would you rather they show up to school with the flu just so they can have a perfect attendance record? No wonder they grow up to be adults that can't spend more than an hour or two a day away from their jobs - we train them that way!

      {"commentId":7305176,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"sarah-toney"}
      • 4 votes
      Reply#2 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:03 AM EDT
      {"commentId":7308216,"authorDomain":"jpenley0725"}

      While I don't necessarily agree that perfect attendance should be exceedingly rewarded - after all, isn't coming to school on a regular basis to be expected? - the contest did not "punish[] kids for getting sick." Punishment would be if those without perfect or near-perfect attendance suffered something adverse. NOT winning a car doesn't qualify as adverse, unless you're one of those selfish, self-centered, self-righteous people who thinks the world owes them everything on a platter with nary an effort to earn it.

      {"commentId":7308216,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"jpenley0725"}
      • 3 votes
      #2.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:20 PM EDT
      {"commentId":7312087,"authorDomain":"smittynvegas"}

      Jennifer, I agree! The fact that one person is rewarded, does not necessarily mean another has been punished. That is a ridiculous assumption, but unfortunately one that seems all too prevalent in society.

      {"commentId":7312087,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"smittynvegas"}
      • 3 votes
      #2.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:15 PM EDT
      {"commentId":7313892,"authorDomain":"gregziglar"}

      What was the definition of near-perfect, and which student parent made the distinction?

      And I thought Elkhart was having financial problems, but they are giving out free cars?

      {"commentId":7313892,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"gregziglar"}
        #2.3 - Wed May 27, 2009 4:32 PM EDT
        {"commentId":7319910,"authorDomain":"thauzualsuzpekt"}

        How do you justify giving a car to a student that won't be able to drive it for 2 years, for any reason, let alone for showing up at school? She won't be able to get a learners permit for at least a year, and even with a permit she can only drive in the daytime with a liscenced driver over the age of 25. And for of all things, perfect attendance! I thought going to school requirement!

        {"commentId":7319910,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"thauzualsuzpekt"}
          #2.4 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:23 PM EDT
          {"commentId":7329712,"authorDomain":"pete-lafromboise"}

          i knew some students that had perfect attendance and it semed like they were always the smart ones. the more your at the school the more you learn. great job i say for those students and there achievements. who wouldnt want to hire someone that shows up for work everyday versus those people that use all there sick leave up every year?

          {"commentId":7329712,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"pete-lafromboise"}
          • 1 vote
          #2.5 - Thu May 28, 2009 1:35 PM EDT
          Reply
          {"commentId":7305360,"authorDomain":"general-sturgis"}

          When I attended Elkhart High School, in the early 60's, perfect attendance was common and did not warrant such uncommon attention. It is a sign of the the deterioration of our values that perfect attendance has become an exceptional achievement.

          {"commentId":7305360,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"general-sturgis"}
          • 2 votes
          Reply#3 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:12 AM EDT
          {"commentId":7305367,"authorDomain":"crowder451"}

          Perfect attendance at my job for 40 years and I don't even get a watch. I hope she appreciates that car. It's probably the last recognition she ever gets.

          Even so; Congratulations on the luck of the draw.

          {"commentId":7305367,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"crowder451"}
          • 1 vote
          Reply#4 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:12 AM EDT
          {"commentId":7317247,"authorDomain":"ryanriverdale"}

          If you are still employed, may I recommend a vacation, a "Mental Health Day" or maybe the middle finger directed to your Superior is more appropriate. Not being acknowledged for such loyalty even after 5 years is a good enough reason to reconsider your position, particularly if they never showed their gratitude with steady pay increases at minimum.

          I hope you're now retired -

          Here is a "thank you" for a job well done for 40 straight years of service from an average Joe Schmo - somehow your short and simple story struck me as more newsworthy than the one highlighted above.

          {"commentId":7317247,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"ryanriverdale"}
          • 1 vote
          #4.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 7:23 PM EDT
          {"commentId":7322918,"authorDomain":"frank-j-1"}

          Hey my commpliments on a well done job. I appreciate it and when you retire I hope you can tell your supervisor to kiss his own a**, as yours is to good for him. I mean not even a thank you or anything? What a jerk.

          {"commentId":7322918,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"frank-j-1"}
          • 2 votes
          #4.2 - Thu May 28, 2009 5:45 AM EDT
          {"commentId":7973725,"authorDomain":"james--98888"}

          Agreed! 40 years, that's a long time in the workforce, and nothing given? And I thought it was bad that this year, Dad got in a fight over 10 years of Perfect Attendance lost by some moron changing a tire in his parking spot.

          {"commentId":7973725,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"james--98888"}
            #4.3 - Wed Jul 1, 2009 5:33 PM EDT
            Reply
            {"commentId":7305592,"authorDomain":"kgonz23"}

            Good grades are a common side effect of attendance. It's too bad some people aren't seeing the good in this. This young lady, who already seems to be doing quite fine, has just learned a lifelong lesson. Good for her!

            {"commentId":7305592,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"kgonz23"}
            • 4 votes
            Reply#5 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:23 AM EDT
            {"commentId":7317899,"authorDomain":"hjack924"}

            Is MSNBC just so overwhelmed with Elkhart that they have to pursue this every day. Others are hurting, but all we hear is Elkhart. Is it an Obama thing?????

            {"commentId":7317899,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"hjack924"}
            • 2 votes
            #5.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 8:04 PM EDT
            {"commentId":7319718,"authorDomain":"rlr524"}

            Exactly! The idiots here are acting as though they know the girl fails her classes and sits out on the school yard smoking weed all day. People are pathetically selfish.

            {"commentId":7319718,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"rlr524"}
            • 1 vote
            #5.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:09 PM EDT
            {"commentId":7363723,"authorDomain":"chocolab"}

            they have been doing this program for awhile now and just because of the Elkhart Project it gets national attention!  the other thing is how their area kids got donations just to have their prom and graduation.  what example is that setting for neighboring counties or other states for that matter?  other people i know had to scrimp and save up for graduation and prom.  sounds like Elkhart kids threw a fit about not being able to afford it, just to see what free stuff they could get from it.  this whole project is starting to sicken me.  the government needs to be helping this nation as a whole!!  what is being in Elkhart helping?  Yeah there might be an electric truck plant coming in a year or two, but how are people suppose to survive in the mean time?

            {"commentId":7363723,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"chocolab"}
              #5.3 - Sat May 30, 2009 12:35 PM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":7306070,"authorDomain":"lbarronton"}

              Attendance is important in school.  Good grades usually follow but my kids have good attendance and  have no chance of winning a car.  They get a certifecate that tells them good job for your attendance.  Although this may be a community that  has been hit hard from the recession there are better ways of helping them.  I hope this young lady will continue to have good attendance and use it to help herself become a better person, one who will give back to society instead of taking "all that she deserves."

              {"commentId":7306070,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"lbarronton"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#6 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:45 AM EDT
              {"commentId":7306132,"authorDomain":"cynthia-ruiz77-1"}

              I didn't realize going to school was a choice. Unless I was sick I was there. They should have added a 4.0 GPA as well as Perfect Attendance. Congrats to the winner though!

              {"commentId":7306132,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cynthia-ruiz77-1"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#7 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:48 AM EDT
              {"commentId":7973757,"authorDomain":"james--98888"}

              Exactly. If I'd known it was a choice to go to school, I've had days I'd have just said, "To heck with this, I'm sleeping in."

              {"commentId":7973757,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"james--98888"}
                #7.1 - Wed Jul 1, 2009 5:35 PM EDT
                Reply
                {"commentId":7306192,"authorDomain":"iofferkicks001"}
                vkalyDeleted
                {"commentId":7306327,"authorDomain":"taylorp"}

                how about a drawing for perfect attendance all four years of high school. Or maybe for making the honor roll all four years. How do you give away a car to a person who isn't even close to being able to drive it? I'm sure the family appreciates it and probably needed it, but it seems like that is the case for every family in this town. This wasn't thought out very well by the school. Congrats to her and her family though....a free car is amazing.

                {"commentId":7306327,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"taylorp"}
                • 1 vote
                Reply#9 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:57 AM EDT
                {"commentId":7307136,"authorDomain":"qman1215"}

                I've shown up to school everyday for the 4 years of high school. I didnt have any free weekends because I was somehow always sick. But going to school everyday doesnt mean better grades. I graduated with a 2.85 GPA.

                {"commentId":7307136,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"qman1215"}
                • 2 votes
                Reply#10 - Wed May 27, 2009 11:32 AM EDT
                {"commentId":7307954,"authorDomain":"chucktrigg"}

                why didn't someone throw in a free "mobile home" there's enough of those lying around.....

                how about next time they have the raffle at the Unemployment Office and let those who have come in every week for a solid year with pefect attendance try to win a car?

                {"commentId":7307954,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"chucktrigg"}
                • 1 vote
                Reply#11 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:08 PM EDT
                {"commentId":7308427,"authorDomain":"blailian"}

                Really? Its a 2002 Dodge Stratus..... Why would they add fuel to the many kids that are already going to be making fun of her. Way to think this through Elkhart Memorial High School. Good Job

                {"commentId":7308427,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"blailian"}
                  Reply#12 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:30 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7308630,"authorDomain":"jaspa"}

                  The cynicism of this world is incredible.  The girl did something admirable, and was rewarded.  And we criticize her school and community.

                  Wow....

                  {"commentId":7308630,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"jaspa"}
                  • 3 votes
                  Reply#13 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:40 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7310456,"authorDomain":"chucktrigg"}

                  admirable?

                  she got an eight year old car for not missing one day of school for a year........

                  if she goes the next three years without missing will she get a full ride scholarship?

                  we read about the trials and tribulations of Elkhart each day - if the community is so concerned I believe this car could have been used by a "family of need" far more..

                  it's called "priorities".

                  {"commentId":7310456,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"chucktrigg"}
                  • 4 votes
                  #13.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:08 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7312126,"authorDomain":"elizabeth062"}

                  it should have been given to a family in need!

                  {"commentId":7312126,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"elizabeth062"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #13.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:17 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7319735,"authorDomain":"rlr524"}

                  No, b dune, it's called being a selfish prick.

                  {"commentId":7319735,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"rlr524"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #13.3 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:10 PM EDT
                  Reply
                  {"commentId":7308877,"authorDomain":"woohoo-wow"}

                  I sure hope Brittany doesn't read any of these comments! What's wrong with you all ? This was one drawing. Sure they could have given another prize, but what's the big deal! Having perfect attendance is a big deal to alot of people. When I was in school, I would have loved to have been able to make perfect attendance. Circumstances with my health kept me from it, but I thought the ones who were able to do it should be rewarded. I think this is an incentive the school is using to try and get more students to strive to complete this same goal. Take a look at the drop out rate, if this gets even one kid to strive to do better in school, I appluade the efforts of the schoool. Congratulations to Brittany on having perfect attencance and winning the car, you deserve it.

                  {"commentId":7308877,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"woohoo-wow"}
                  • 4 votes
                  Reply#14 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:51 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7311491,"authorDomain":"catmusic"}

                  What is wrong with our educators today.  I thought the purpose of going to school was to get an education.  That not being ignorant was the reward for going to school.  Now that doesn't seem to the case.  Students need a car, gift certificate or some other kind of tangible reward for getting an education.  How sad to watch our education system sinking to a "We'll pay you to learn" mentality.

                  {"commentId":7311491,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"catmusic"}
                  • 3 votes
                  #14.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:51 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7312456,"authorDomain":"csam18"}

                  It's a reward, not payment, I assumed people knew the difference. I remember back in school when we recieved happy face stickers for doing well. Wether it be for attendance or grades, it's still a reward system that till this day promotes competition, and competition leads to growth. It occurs in schools, it occurs in the work force. People keep bringing up the fact that she's being rewarded for her attendance and not grades -- do you honestly think kids with poor attendance get good grades? I'm sure kids with good attendence let alone perfect attendance are more like to recieve better grades, pretty obvious there.

                  {"commentId":7312456,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"csam18"}
                  • 2 votes
                  #14.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:31 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7324594,"authorDomain":"nvolz"}

                  Hats off to you Tammy w. COME ON PEOPLE....stop being to petty and jealous and let this kid be happy.

                  {"commentId":7324594,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"nvolz"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #14.3 - Thu May 28, 2009 9:31 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":7324654,"authorDomain":"cniht"}

                  I had perfect attendance each and every year from the time I was 5 to the time I was 13. I missed 2 days due to an adverse reaction to a yellow fever shot for an overseas trip and another 2 weeks when I was a senior due to a prolonged hospital stay.

                  I did not get a car, or any type of cash or asset reward for all the years I had perfect attendance. I was expected to go to school and I went. As a child it was my 'job'.

                  It is insane that we are rewarding people for the most basic of things. I am sure that the young lady will enjoy her car. I think the adults at the school and in the community that organized this little escapade should be thrashed in the street, publicly.

                  The perfect word for this contest: Pathetic.

                  {"commentId":7324654,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cniht"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #14.4 - Thu May 28, 2009 9:35 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":7333584,"authorDomain":"lgullive"}
                  I think the adults at the school and in the community that organized this little escapade should be thrashed in the street, publicly.

                  Get a grip! and a life!

                  {"commentId":7333584,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"lgullive"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #14.5 - Thu May 28, 2009 4:29 PM EDT
                  Reply
                  {"commentId":7309028,"authorDomain":"thestaubs"}

                  Some generous community members in our area offer bikes to the kids with perfect attendance at the end of the year.  Although their intentions are good, ultimately kids go to school when they clearly should stay home because of illness.  I'm sick of my kids catching what they have so they can win a bike.  I love the idea of rewards but let's reward effort, grades or behavior.

                  {"commentId":7309028,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"thestaubs"}
                  • 2 votes
                  Reply#15 - Wed May 27, 2009 12:59 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7326395,"authorDomain":"a-dad66"}

                  Exactly! Kids get sick through no fault of their own, and when that happens they should be kept home. This insistence on perfect (or even near-perfect) attendance these days is definitely sending the wrong signal.

                  {"commentId":7326395,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"a-dad66"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #15.1 - Thu May 28, 2009 11:08 AM EDT
                  Reply
                  {"commentId":7309305,"authorDomain":"jsmccolley"}

                  Admirable? Really? Not getting sick is now considered to be admirable? My 11 year old daughter cries when she has to miss school because she's sick, because she's worried about missing school. Does that count? Can someone give my daughter a car for that? Good Lord.

                  {"commentId":7309305,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"jsmccolley"}
                  • 1 vote
                  Reply#16 - Wed May 27, 2009 1:12 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7319752,"authorDomain":"rlr524"}

                  Incredible has nailed the point of most of the others here. Waaaaaaaaaa!!! Sniffle!!!! It should have been me!!! What about me!!!!!! MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.

                  {"commentId":7319752,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"rlr524"}
                  • 2 votes
                  #16.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:12 PM EDT
                  Reply
                  {"commentId":7309866,"authorDomain":"cprice-2"}

                  How sad that people take a happy moment for this young girl and fill it with resentment and a " why not me ? " attitude. So depressing to see so many sour grapes.

                  {"commentId":7309866,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cprice-2"}
                  • 4 votes
                  Reply#17 - Wed May 27, 2009 1:41 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":7327105,"authorDomain":"CRUSSORX"}

                  so sad to see all the negative feedback for a community trying to show support for each other--

                  {"commentId":7327105,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"CRUSSORX"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #17.1 - Thu May 28, 2009 11:42 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":7973817,"authorDomain":"james--98888"}

                  Agreed. Today's society revolves around this:

                  Me first, you last.

                  {"commentId":7973817,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"james--98888"}
                    #17.2 - Wed Jul 1, 2009 5:39 PM EDT
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":7309935,"authorDomain":"jsmccolley"}

                    I wasn't being literal, genius.

                    {"commentId":7309935,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"jsmccolley"}
                      Reply#18 - Wed May 27, 2009 1:44 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":7310329,"authorDomain":"lgullive"}

                      Why would you think Meezo was directing his/her comment to you, unless you think it deserved? There are plenty of comments on this board that would qualify.

                      Congratulations to the winner.

                      {"commentId":7310329,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"lgullive"}
                      • 2 votes
                      #18.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:02 PM EDT
                      Reply
                      {"commentId":7310171,"authorDomain":"cprice-2"}

                      I wasn't specifically talking to you, Genius. Think the world revolves around you much ?

                      {"commentId":7310171,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cprice-2"}
                      • 3 votes
                      Reply#19 - Wed May 27, 2009 1:55 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":7310395,"authorDomain":"csam18"}

                      I agree Meezo, nothing but a bunch of sad individuals in here. Can't even be happy for a young girl. "When I was her age, perfect attendance was normal", "I worked for 90 years and didn't get as much as a hug", "My daughter got sick and missed school, now she won't get a car" blah blah, shut up please and just be happy for another persons good fortune. But I guess all you negative people can continue to cry about the news because frankly, she's not going to be reading any of this anyways, she'll be staring out her window at a nice car waiting for her when she gets her license. ( Yes -- nice car, because most kids her age don't get cars and if they did, it's usually some run down beater )

                      {"commentId":7310395,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"csam18"}
                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#20 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:05 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":7320853,"authorDomain":"cab26715"}

                      A 2002 Dodge IS a "run down beater".

                      American-made cars aren't known for their reliability, especially Dodge, which is owned by Chrysler, a company currently in financial trouble.

                      Good luck getting service for your car when you are ready to drive it, Brittany!

                      {"commentId":7320853,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cab26715"}
                      • 1 vote
                      #20.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 11:31 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":7321031,"authorDomain":"cab26715"}

                      That car will be about 10 to 12 years old by the time she is ready to drive it with her learner's permit.

                      Also, she will have a very hard time finding parts and service for her car in the future, due to the fact that Chrysler has currently filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, and could potentially be no more, after the Treasury and Chrysler are done playing "The Bailout Game" (using taxpayer dollars, and increasing the National Debt).

                      [I subscribe to The Wall Street Journal daily and read a lot of reputable news articles online].

                      {"commentId":7321031,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cab26715"}
                      • 1 vote
                      #20.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 11:47 PM EDT
                      Reply
                      {"commentId":7310552,"authorDomain":"cooking-4-hubby"}

                      As a teacher at one of the Elkhart schools (Central to be exact), I would like to draw your attention to the part where it says that students with near-perfect attendance were also included. Staying home because you're ill is one thing; staying home to skip school is another. It is a sad fact of life that we do have to reward students for coming to school, but this program has helped improve attendance immensely. Students can't learn who don't come to school.

                      I also want to bring attention to the BPA students. They didn't have funds in reserve from previous years because this is their first year. It is amazing to have two students qualify for national competitions in the first year the organization has existed at school. They've worked hard trying to raise funds by selling coupon books, holding bake sales and a fundraiser at a local restaurant. They have received some community support, but times are tight and there are many organizations who need financial support.

                      Let's celebrate these teenagers who are being recognized for something good. Isn't that what we want to see?

                      {"commentId":7310552,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cooking-4-hubby"}
                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#21 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:11 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":7315669,"authorDomain":"catwoman-1"}

                      Thank you "Look on the bright side" I appreciate hearing what you have to say. So sorry your school wasn't able to get the support to do the same raffle.

                      {"commentId":7315669,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"catwoman-1"}
                        #21.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 5:54 PM EDT
                        {"commentId":7319788,"authorDomain":"rlr524"}

                        Thank you, also, Look on the bright side. Most of this garbage really stems from the fact that most people simply hate teenagers and really don't want to see them being recognized for doing something good because it shatters all their pretty little stereotypes.

                        {"commentId":7319788,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"rlr524"}
                        • 1 vote
                        #21.2 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:14 PM EDT
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":7310843,"authorDomain":"dixonj"}

                        Before I'm accused of "sour grapes", let me first say that I think it's great that this young lady won a free car.

                        The concern I have with this type of contest is that it develops a "me, me, me" attitude instead of building people who are concerned about the people around them. More than likely, this young lady or someone else who had perfect attendance was sick during the school year and went to school anyway because they didn't want to ruin their chance to win a free car. They thought only of themselves and not the people they then infected.

                        Do you want your child catching swine flu from someone who just couldn't miss school because they had to have perfect attendance?

                        Make the reward contingent on good grades, honor role or something else where you're not having a negative impact on others.

                        {"commentId":7310843,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"dixonj"}
                        • 2 votes
                        Reply#22 - Wed May 27, 2009 2:24 PM EDT
                        {"commentId":7319886,"authorDomain":"xrobin58x"}

                        The only "me me me" displayed appears to be from some jealous parents in this thread. I'd also really doubt that any of those eligible for the contest came to school so sick that they caused massive absenses from others. If it inspires others elsewhere to hold similar contests and that increases attendance then this news story worked. And fwiw there already are sufficient rewards for those on the honor role. This at least rewards those who are trying as well.

                        {"commentId":7319886,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"xrobin58x"}
                        • 2 votes
                        #22.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 10:21 PM EDT
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":7311720,"authorDomain":"woohoo-wow"}

                        Some of you have concerns about your child getting sick from other kids going to school sick to win a contest. What about the ones who are required to go sick because if they don't they will fail their grade due to too many absences. I live in SC, and a child can only miss 10 days in a school year. If they miss any more, they are held back. It doesn't matter why they miss the days.

                        {"commentId":7311720,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"woohoo-wow"}
                          Reply#23 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:00 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":7321089,"authorDomain":"cab26715"}

                          Missing 10 days due to sickness (or other matters) is A LOT.

                          How often does one get seriously ill or have a death in the family in a Ten Month time period (typical school year)?

                          {"commentId":7321089,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cab26715"}
                            #23.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 11:51 PM EDT
                            {"commentId":7322006,"authorDomain":"stuckup1"}

                            Here's hoping you don't have a kid with epilepsy. We're told that 1% of the entire population has seizures of some sort, that's a lot of school kids, and a lot of missed class time. I've also been told that mono keeps kids out of school for a minimum of three weeks straight.

                            {"commentId":7322006,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"stuckup1"}
                              #23.2 - Thu May 28, 2009 1:26 AM EDT
                              Reply
                              {"commentId":7311877,"authorDomain":"csam18"}

                              Forcing yourself to go to school even though you're feeling under the weather is just getting prepared for how it will be in the real world. You are only provided with a hand full of sick days when at work, so when you run out, you just have to suck it up -- no rewards there.

                              Tammy is also right, same thing applied back in my High School.

                              {"commentId":7311877,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"csam18"}
                              • 2 votes
                              Reply#24 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:07 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":7321063,"authorDomain":"cab26715"}

                              "Forcing yourself to go to school even though you're feeling under the weather" huh?!?!

                              So, let's get all of my classmates sick too?

                              Even if I had Swine Flu?

                              {"commentId":7321063,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"cab26715"}
                              • 1 vote
                              #24.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 11:49 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":7327924,"authorDomain":"bjornar-1"}

                              Of course the most rational example is to jump straght to swine flu. How many highschoolers play that crap of "mom, dad, I feel really sick" and excuse themselves out of the responsibility of going to school. If, as a parent, you are concerned for your child's health, make sure they wash their hands often, or have them sport a michael jackson painter's mask if you're that paranoid. In elementary school I can remember winning a perfect attendance drawing that got me a large lollypop type thing--and boy did that destroy my motivation getting rewarded for something expected of me! Wait, I still went on through school having perfect or near-perfect attendance. My parents gave me an allowance for doing my chores as well, but wasn't that just rewarding me for doing something I should do simply to support the family? Wasn't my reward the "character" it built in me (Calvin and Hobbes anyone?)

                              {"commentId":7327924,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"bjornar-1"}
                                #24.2 - Thu May 28, 2009 12:19 PM EDT
                                Reply
                                {"commentId":7311878,"authorDomain":"nonyabiznes"}

                                So many haters.... it makes me sad.

                                {"commentId":7311878,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"nonyabiznes"}
                                • 1 vote
                                Reply#25 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:07 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":7313965,"authorDomain":"gregziglar"}

                                And this is the "nice" message board.

                                {"commentId":7313965,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"gregziglar"}
                                • 1 vote
                                #25.1 - Wed May 27, 2009 4:35 PM EDT
                                Reply
                                {"commentId":7312075,"authorDomain":"csam18"}

                                No matter how positive the cause, there will always be those who find negativity out of it. It is sad, and it makes me sad too but only for a few minutes. :)

                                {"commentId":7312075,"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275","authorDomain":"csam18"}
                                • 2 votes
                                Reply#26 - Wed May 27, 2009 3:14 PM EDT
                                Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3
                                {"canLink":false,"threadId":"588528","isPrivate":false}
                                Leave a Comment:
                                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                {"threadId":"588528","contentId":"2867275"}
                                Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                Stop TrackingStop Tracking